With lean-burn operating strategies being built into many of today’s gasoline direct-injection and gasoline compression ignition engines, it’s important to build a foundational knowledge of how fuel trims work in the real world. Working up to this month’s column, I found a fuel trim question on a professional technical help forum involving a 2006 Nissan Xterra equipped with the 4.0L V6 engine and manual transmission. I couldn’t find a “fix” posted, but the Xterra’s fuel trim problem is a real-world example of how a fuel trim diagnosis can go awry, so I decided to use its trim numbers and P2A00 diagnostic trouble code (DTC) to illustrate basic fuel trim diagnostics.
At this point, I’m not sure that the words “basic” and “fuel trim” can exist in the same universe. Refreshing my memory through a relatively recent copy of a 60-page training manual that’s chock full of fuel trim-related information, I found that I can’t tackle related topics like engine load calculations and air-fuel ratio sensor operation in this space. For that reason, I recommend that you expand upon the content of this column by taking a four-hour basic or an eight-hour advanced fuel trim training class at some future date. In the meantime, let’s figure out why our Xterra’s P2A00 DTC was apparently so hard to diagnose in a technical help format.
According to freeze-frame data, the engine control module (ECM) set a P2A00 DTC (bank 1 upstream sensor lean) at 1,500 rpm at 27 mph. After replacing the bank 1 (B1) AFR sensor, the P2A00 repeated after 200 miles, then would return within 20 minutes after clearing. Looking at Nissan service information, a P2A00 DTC sets when “the output voltage computed from the sensor B1 signal is shifted to the lean side for a specified period.”
TOTAL FUEL TRIMS
B1 Long-term fuel trim (LFT) = +1.6% and B1 short-term fuel trim (SFT) = +1.4%. B2 LFT = -2.3% and B2 SFT = +9.4%. The B2 LFT and SFT numbers are bouncing around, so let’s get a clearer picture by adding the SFT and LFT numbers from each bank to get for a total fuel trim of +3% on B1 and +7.1% on B2. See Photo 1.
RIGHT AND LEFT
While P2A00 indicates a B1 lean condition, short-term fuel trims indicate that the ECM is adding 7.1% fuel to correct a lean condition on B2. Following the P2A00 DTC, the B1 and B2 numbers have been transposed in the original help request, which is why the original diagnosis went off-track. If we swap the B1 data with the B2 data, that data will then correspond to the P2A00 DTC (B1 lean). We now have the correct fuel trim data needed to solve our problem.
FUEL TRIM CALCULATIONS
In brief, fuel trim calculations are designed to correct an excessively rich or lean air/fuel ratio by increasing or decreasing fuel injector pulse width. The upstream AFR sensor inputs to the ECM normally indicate whether fuel must be added or subtracted to maintain the programmed air/fuel ratio. In our Nissan’s case, P2A00 is setting because, on average, the ECM is adding more fuel to bank #1 from idle to 1,500 rpm than to bank #2. See Photo 2.
UNEQUAL FUEL TRIMS
As a rule of thumb, both cylinder banks shouldn’t exceed plus or minus 5% LFT under normal operating conditions. The ECM obviously doesn’t have full fuel control, otherwise the ECM would be able to produce a 14.7:1 a/f ratio on B1, especially at 1,500 rpm.
Since faulty mass air flow inputs or low fuel pressure should affect fuel trims on both banks equally, we can rule them out for the moment. And, since the fuel trim corrections disappear after 1,500 rpm, when the engine is under a mild load, we can assume that the B1 +7% is being caused by an air leak into the bank #1 intake or exhaust systems.
TESTING FOR EXHAUST LEAKS
Our Xterra has two heated 6-wire AFR sensors in the upstream positions and two heated 4-wire zirconia oxygen sensors in the downstream positions. Since exhaust gases flow in pulses, negative pressure waves are created in the exhaust system, which can draw ambient air through a leaking exhaust manifold, cracked AFR sensor mount or exhaust pipe joint to create a P2A00 (B1 lean) or P2A03 (B2 lean) DTC.
A simple test for exhaust leaks is to create positive pressure in the exhaust by blocking the outlets with shop rags with the engine running. Looking at our scan tool display, the positive short-term fuel trim corrections should drop to nearly zero if the exhaust leak is large enough to set a P2A00 in the diagnostic memory.
TESTING FOR INTAKE LEAKS
At this point, the most likely cause of Xterra’s P2A00 DTC is unmetered air entering the intake manifold through a broken intake gasket or a vacuum supply hose. Having eliminated the exhaust system as a cause, we can assume that we have an air leak into a bank 1 intake port that tends to disappear as the engine approaches 1,500 rpm.
To be reliable, smoke machine testing requires a mild positive pressure inside the intake and exhaust systems. To achieve this, the air intake, all vacuum ports and the exhaust outlets must be sealed. That said, a test should be conducted at cold-soak and at full operating temperature to locate temperature-sensitive leaks.
Intake manifold leak detection can also involve adding fuel to the offending cylinder by carefully spraying a flammable hydrocarbon around the intake sealing surfaces. In most cases, an aerosol throttle body cleaner is sprayed around suspected leakage points. Do not use chlorine-based brake parts cleaners that emit poisonous chlorine gas from the exhaust.
Some professional technicians prefer propane testing because it’s more controllable and, therefore, more precise. Regardless of the method, any technician should understand the safety issues surrounding the use of flammable hydrocarbon testing methods. Never, for example, spray an aerosol or point a propane wand at the alternator or at secondary ignition system components with the engine running. In addition to the engine wiring harnesses and components being damaged, you can suffer severe burns to the face and hands.
COLLECTING SFT DATA
Using propane as an example, connect a scan tool and cold-start the engine. Set the propane wand on low volume and probe around and under the intake gasket areas. An intake air leak is present when the SFT begins subtracting from the current positive fuel trim numbers. If no leak is found, keep testing until the engine thermostat opens. At some point between cold soak and hot-soak temperatures, the intake is developing an air leak, otherwise the P2A00 DTC wouldn’t appear.
FUEL TRIM RELEARNS
Once repaired, Nissan requires a self-learning procedure to clear the existing fuel trim data from the ECM’s adaptive memory. Most preferred, Nissan’s Consult II scan tool can directly perform the self-learning procedure. To illustrate one suggested aftermarket method, with the engine running at operating temp, turn the engine off and disconnect the mass air flow sensor. Restart and let the engine idle for at least three seconds to set a P0102 MAF DTC. Turn the engine off and clear the P0102 DTC. Then, start the engine and let it idle for at least 10 minutes to relearn the fuel trims. Other methods can be used as well, but make sure that the self-learning procedure is correct for your Nissan application.
Fuel Trim Terminology: Sometimes It Is What It Isn’t
- SHORT-TERM FUEL TRIMS: The ECM uses feedback from the upstream AFR to adjust air/fuel ratios to programmed values, which can range from a slightly rich 13:1 to a very lean 22:1 as used on Mazda’s Homogenous Charge Compression Ignition (HCCI) engines.
- When the AFR detects excess fuel, the ECM subtracts fuel by decreasing injector pulse widths.
- When the AFR sensor detects insufficient fuel, the ECM adds fuel by increasing fuel injector pulse widths to compensate.
- LONG-TERM FUEL TRIMS: Since there’s a slight time lapse between AFR feedback and ECM correction, the ECM uses SFT data to create a long-term fuel trim (LFT) correction to bridge the time gap.
- The ECM normally prepares the engine for its next start-up by retaining adaptive values, which corrects for different altitudes and ambient temperatures.
- TOTAL FUEL TRIM: As illustrated in the above text, fuel trim percentages don’t always arrive in neat packages. To establish an average fuel trim percentage, use this formula: SFT + LFT = Total Fuel Trim.
- DOWNSTREAM FUEL TRIMS: Since modern vehicles might also use downstream sensor inputs to correct fuel trim, total fuel trim might be more accurately expressed as SFT + LFT + RFT.
- DOWNSTREAM OXYGEN SENSORS: Narrow-range zirconia sensors (0.00 to 1.00-volt ranges) are normally used in downstream applications.
- DOWNSTREAM VOLTAGES: With the catalytic converter at operating temperature, downstream voltages normally report in a range of 600-700 millivolts (mV). If the B1 upstream AFR indicates lean, that value might be verified by a B1 downstream O2 sensor indicating less than 600 mV.
- REAR FUEL TRIM: Since rear fuel trim (RFT) operating strategies vary widely among manufacturers, you’ll have to learn as you go.
- LEAN DTCS: In general, a + 25% or greater fuel trim correction will store P0171/P0174 DTCs.
- MISFIRE DTCS: A large intake air leak can also create a lean misfire and store a cylinder-specific P300-series DTC.
Article courtesy ImportCar.