The Problem With Color: How Did I Choose To Mix This? -

The Problem With Color: How Did I Choose To Mix This?

Adapted from Carl Wilson’s article in BodyShop Business.


When mixing paint, having a purpose to achieve the results you’re after will lead to better color match.

Without spray-out cards, you’re just guessing as to color match.

In the April issue, we discussed fundamentals, pre-existing paint problems and painter responsibility. (Click HERE for the article.) Briefly, let’s under-score painter responsibility:

• Turn the mixing bank on and ensure complete agitator lid engagement.
• Consciously practice consistent application.
• Make a spray-out card, being mindful of your spray techniques for consistency’s sake.
• Take responsibility for the color – if you’re not happy with it on the card, you’ll likely not be happy with it on the car. If it happens that a mismatch slipped through the cracks for whatever reason and you’re now looking at it on the car, admit it. Don’t excuse it; accept that it’s your responsibility and you’re the one to fix it.
• Plot the course to correct it, reminding yourself that the only thing worse than painting it twice is painting it three times.
• Do whatever is required to keep it out of the booth a third time.

First, let’s back the train up to before we painted the job and mixed the paint. How did we arrive at the decision to mix this formula?


It Always Matches

It’s incredible how many painters tell me, “I always mix this, and it always matches.” Go back and read about OEM inconsistencies and other pre-existing conditions. It might match often, but nothing ever “always matches.” And without a spray-out card, you’re just guessing.

While some experienced painters may brag, “I keep the list of what matches in my head,” I don’t recommend relying on memory for this. Depending on the system, you may have more than 25,000 color formulas, and as many as 3,500 active formulas.

So what should you consider when making the choice to mix this over that? What brought us to this decision? Well, I believe it derives from the attitude demonstrated in this quote by Jeff Lee: “It’s this way because I wanted it this way; it’s not a fluke.”

Therefore, with purpose we progress. We do not guess which formula variant to mix; we use the tools available to guide us. The best color assessment tool available to you, hands-down, will be your personal color library. However, given how rare that is, we’ll consider that which is available otherwise.

Common color tools include:

• Color chip books and color chips.
• A 1-800-“Call the lab when you have a question regarding the possibility of an additional formula not published” phone number.
• The VIN, which contains pertinent color information such as country and/or plant that can narrow the search.
• You – as you gain experience with a system and possess knowledge regarding a particular toner or toners.
• The toner chart.
• A color camera, which many systems have.


Gathering Info

We’ll start with gathering the correct information: color code and vintage. The 11th digit of the VIN of one particular automaker will reveal the plant the car was manufactured in. The first digit in the VIN of another maker will reveal the country of origin. These differences can matter. Inside your color chip book, you’ll likely find a dissection of the VIN and how to use that information in selecting a formula. Often, that information will lead you to a color chip that’s intended to be a representation of the mixed color.

Not all color chips are created equal; some are better than others. This further strengthens the case for making your own color library, but we’re working with the existing chips. Regardless, we need to be certain we’re viewing a panel relevant to the repair. It doesn’t matter how the color will look to the hood if we’re painting a rear bumper. Furthermore, the proper viewing angle is crucial. Regarding that rear bumper, you shouldn’t be sitting on the ground looking at the face of the color. Far more important here is the sidetone, or the angle presented when viewing the color by standing next to the car.

Proper lighting is essential. Not just for the proper spectrum, but also for adequate illumination. The sun works well depending where in the country you live as well as the time of day, keeping in mind that the morning sunlight is a bit different than the noon sunlight, which is different from the evening sunlight. My preference is to utilize a handheld, color-corrected light. This allows me to move my light source in relation to the vehicle to see the different viewing angles as opposed to moving the vehicle in relation to the sun. The handheld unit also allows me to view a color inside the spraybooth.


Cleaning the Panel

OK, we’re almost ready to start viewing and analyzing. But first, we need to clean the panel we’re going to compare. Wash it off and compound it with a small polisher. The small polisher results in a truer color by removing the environmental contaminants aggravated by UV exposure, which stubbornly resists hand-polishing. The heat generated from the polisher eliminates this and has the added benefit of restoring any loss of gloss due to age. The degree of gloss affects perceived color.


Sidetones and Reverse Tinting

So, we’ve cleaned the panel, looked up the proper code and retrieved the appropriate color chip(s). With the proper light illumination at the correct viewing angles, we describe what we see. The vehicle is blue, but we say, “The car is redder in the sidetone,” so we check to see if there is a chip that corresponds. If there is, great! If there isn’t, then we call the color lab and ask if they have a formula variant that’s is “redder in the sidetone” – a tactic that has worked for me more than once. Oftentimes, they’ll have something in their resources that is not included in your system updates.

Or, depending how accurate your color chips are, if you know they closely represent the formula mix, then you can reverse tint. Reverse tinting is withholding a portion of a toner from the mix, as opposed to live tinting where we’re adding to the mix.

To reverse tint, you reverse the descriptive vernacular. Rather than “The car is…,” you say, “The card is…,” thereby pointing yourself toward the solution. If the “card is greener in the sidetone than the car,” then you can look at the toners within that mix and, using the descriptive toner chart, determine which toner is the offender and either leave a measured portion out or replace a measured portion with an appropriate toner.

At this point, you’re going to make a spray-out card to view. I would suggest that since you’re already making the spray-out, you might as well save it and start a color library. Full documentation on the reverse will ensure that you can remix this color any time.

If you have a color camera, a tech rep from the manufacturer can assist you in learning how to properly use it. The camera is a great tool, and each one will have its own nuances, but starting with a clean panel to snap a photo is universal. The camera will often get you a blendable match right out of the gate; other times, it’s simply going to get you to a starting point.

The broader point to all of this is to achieve the results you’re after on purpose, not haphazardly. Have a path you consistently follow for making the decision to mix what you’ve mixed.





You May Also Like

Jump Starting an EV

If an EV with a full battery won’t start, here’s how you can get it up and running.

Here’s a real-world scenario: A customer brings their EV into your shop for service, and it’s been there for quite a while because the parts are on backorder. After a few weeks, you get in the vehicle to move it out of your way, and the ignition won’t turn on. It’s acting like the battery is dead, so what do you do now?

Spark Plug Fouling

Understanding why plugs get dirty.

Electric Power Steering Diagnostics

Load management for steering systems.

Ball Joint Inspection

It’s important to remember not to miss a worn joint. If a ball joint fails, the driver loses control of the vehicle.

Tips For Understanding Belt Friction And Tension

Serpentine belts and automatic tensioners more than tripled belt life.

Other Posts

Electric Power Steering Evolution

Diagnosing electric power steering systems requires an understanding of voltage, current and loads.

Solving Intermittent Overheating

New cooling systems anticipate and influence changes in coolant temperature. 

Brake Pad Errors and Mismatches

In order to make the right selection, you must do your homework while still remaining skeptical.

Replacing Master Cylinders

The most common problems that occur in the master cylinder are wear in the piston bore and piston seal failure.