Superchargers: Pros And Cons

Superchargers: Pros And Cons

Drivers generally look to superchargers for the instant throttle response, not fuel economy.

Superchargers are synonymous with making horsepower, especially in drag racing, gaining popularity and recognition as a viable power adder. However, they’re not the best option for saving fuel.

While most automakers are currently fascinated with employing turbochargers to make up for lost horsepower due to lower-displacement engines, do superchargers have a place in the current automotive climate? Indeed, this power-adder is more commonly found in the performance arena, because it produces power at lower rpm and comes in a smaller package than a turbocharger. But there are some downsides.

Roots-Style

A roots-style supercharger often is referred to as a “blower,” as it sits atop the intake manifold and blows an air/fuel charge into the cylinders. Roots systems use lobed vanes that pull air into the housing as it’s driven from a belt off the crankshaft. This system makes plenty of power but is less efficient than other types of superchargers. These early systems didn’t have any form of cooling, which was a problem because heat is a factor in any positive-displacement system.

Years ago, it was a lot more challenging to control a supercharged application because they were connected to a carburetor. But carburetors were meant to work with vacuum – not under pressure – so when you introduce charged air, the fuel and air leak like a sprinkler if it’s not tuned just right.

Twin-Screw

People often confuse “roots”-style superchargers with “twin-screw”-type superchargers. The misconception comes from the belief that both superchargers are identical in operating principle and efficiency. But they’re not. The twin-screw concept has been proven to be more efficient than the roots style, with a cooler air charge and lower parasitic loss. More manufacturers prefer the twin-screw today for this reason. Ford used it for its most powerful and prestigious production car ever: the Ford GT. Mercedes has switched to the twin-screw as well as Dodge with its 700-horsepower Hellcat. A Kenne Bell 3.6 twin-screw is employed in all of Shelby’s 750-, 800- and 850-horsepower Super Snakes.

Centrifugal

A centrifugal supercharger doesn’t have counter-rotating rotors but uses a compressor design similar to the turbocharger’s impeller wheel. Boost builds up as rpm increases like a turbo, but throttle response is better. Superchargers are a great power-adder option, as they offer instant throttle response and aren’t as complex to install as turbochargers.

Electric

There is one exciting addition to the supercharger stable, and it comes from Audi. They’ve developed an electric supercharger to be used in conjunction with a twin-turbo setup that virtually eliminates turbo lag. The charger is driven from a 48-volt power supply that feeds a 7-kilowatt electric motor capable of spinning up to 70,000 rpm. The electric supercharger will come on first until the engine reaches the low- to mid-rpm range and the other turbos come into play.

Customers generally look to superchargers for the instant throttle response, not fuel economy. These belt-driven blowers are less efficient than turbos because they use power from the engine to drive it, creating a parasitic loss. Superchargers are easier to install and tune because you don’t have to worry about wastegates and boost controllers, and tricky plumbing. In some cases, you can get 12 to 13 pounds of boost right out of the box from kits available in the aftermarket.

This article appeared in Counterman.

You May Also Like

Fuel Tanks and Pumps

The behavior of the fuel wells, pumps & sending units are often misdiagnosed, leading to fuel pumps being replaced.

Automakers have installed saddle-style tanks on several car models for more than a decade. This style of tank uses two wells, one on either side of a driveshaft or exhaust system. On the bright side, this position optimizes luggage compartment capacity, fuel volume and crash safety. However, the behavior of the fuel wells, pumps and sending units are often misdiagnosed, leading to fuel pumps being replaced unnecessarily.

Turbochargers on Minis

No matter if it is a BMW or MINI, when the engine stops turning, the oil flowing to the turbocharger stops.

Batteries For Stop/Start Systems

On all stop/start vehicles, the life and performance of the battery are measured by the vehicle in several ways.

Diagnostic Procedures For Stop/Start Systems

Stop/start technology is more than just a switch wired to the brake pedal and starter.

Understanding Engine Timing- Chains, Gears and Belts

Engine timing is critical for overall performance.

Other Posts

Air Filters and Fuel Trims

Modern engines rely on precise airflow and oxygen sensor data for optimal performance.

Understanding Fuel Injection

Though many different terms have been used for the technology, it really just comes down to indirect or direct.

Deciphering An Engine Misfire Code

Many changing factors must be met to pass a misfire monitor.

Five Spark Plug Service And Replacement Tips

Most articles will tell you to use a torque wrench, but they never explain why.